I've been off line trying to write a paper on teleology and modern science, or rather dysteleological interpretations thereof. Hard yacka! Much of the focus has been on cosmology and books like Paul Davies' The Goldilocks Enigma, which is well worth a read.
However, it is hard not to touch on evolution, since Paley's watchmaker argument and Dawkins' The Blind Watchmaker are of central importance, and it is evolution that is the sticking point for many.
There are several Christian models of creation, and I take it that it is a defining doctrine for Christians that God is creator. To quote (roughly) Brueggemann (sic) in his commentary on Gen 1.1 'The creator creates creation'. So what are the options?
1. 'Creationist' - either 6 day (young earth) or 6 eons (old earth). The bedrock of this is an insistence on biblical inerrancy where the bible must be lead (for the most part) literally, and cannot be in error on scientific facts. It is easy to avoid a dysteleological interpretation of evolution with this view because one merely trumps theory with theology. However, the retreat into denial doesn't help deal with the real problems observed - natural/evolved evil, etc.
The opposite of inerrancy is not necessarily errancy, and many feel that the irony with this view is that it uses modernism and falls into the trap that scientific knowledge is the unprivileged viewpoint (indeed the only valid one).
2. Intelligent design is a bit different in that it seeks to prove scientifically that there is a designer by finding gaps in the science - ideas like irreducible complexity. Stephen Meyer describes the theological concept as limited partnership because theology provides genuine scientific hypotheses to test.
There are a few issues with this view. Firstly, examples of irreducible complexity disappear with increased understanding (the rotating flagella is an example of this). Secondly, an emphasis on chance and spontaneity is misguided. Biologists like Simon Conway Morris point towards the idea that convergence in evolution shows us that evolutionary phase space is limited, and here we can see direction in evolution that may come from a designer. Thirdly, it suggests that God's creation is broken, that Howard Van Tills robust formational economy isn't robust. Maybe even that God is an inept designer.
3. Third is the process God, too tied up with the creation itself and not the creator ex nihilio of traditional Christian theology. Although not fully fleshed out, the bible seems to support the doctrine, leaving process theology high and dry.
4. Deism says God winds things up and lets it go. Enough said.
5. A popular model with some Christians is often called theistic evolution. God uses the process of evolution to produce life, consciousness and humanity to enter into relationship with Him. The idea I like, but the name I do no. Theism can mean many things, but most who use this term are thinking about the God of the bible. The emphasis is on evolution, not creation, creating the idea that the young earthers have a copy right on the word.
Others prefer evolutionary creationism, and this is closer to the right idea since the emphasis is both on the ontology (creation) and the method (creation). However, if not specified a little more, this could easily become Deistic in its emphasis.
Emergence is a trendy concept, the idea that something new comes from a collection, i.e. the whole is greater than the sum of its parts, that greater complexity emerges with time. We see this with clouds, fire, etc but supremely with life. Life emerges with non-life, and you use biology not physics to do a lot of the work. However, one can be epistemic (descriptive) or ontological (something really different and non-reductive) about emergence. To be an aid in the creation/teleological area, we need to emphasize the later idea.
Again, if creation is emergence, then it can also be Deistic. Conway Morris is very cautious, but I take it that the biblical idea of election is also helpful. Psalm 8 speaks of an elective view of humanity in the face of the immensity of creation. Creation is therefore emergent and elective if we don't wish to reduce God to the watch winder. This isn't ID in that creation could do everything on its own.
A quick example for now. Neanderthals probably went extinct due to climate variability and resource competition with Homo Sapiens (i.e. us, specifically Cro Magnon). The bible has a strong anti-idolatry polemic based on YHWH's control over weather. Late Neanderthal culture shows advancement which may be imitative or may be genuinely internal. Further, there are hints of burial, care for the incapacitated, etc. Could Neanderthals have become Imago Dei (image of God) and God elected Homo Sapiens?
Enough wild speculation for now, back to work.
Diatribe on a variety of topics, attempting to link science, faith and philosophy, as well as discussion on pedagogy, blended learning and Web 2.0.
Erstaunen bin ich da.
Showing posts with label teleology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label teleology. Show all posts
Wednesday, September 12, 2007
Friday, August 03, 2007
Sperm whales and science
Fans of Douglas Adams will be familiar with the scene in the Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy where the Infinite Improbability Drive turns two nuclear missiles into a bowl of petunias and a small sperm whale. The small sperm whale wonders why it is here and what is its purpose in life (technically speaking, its telos). This always made me laugh.
However, reading part of The God Delusion we find Richard Dawkins putting Douglas Adams up as a poster boy for atheism motivated by science. Adams has his epiphany after reading The Selfish Gene and embracing a new enthusiasm for atheism and absurdity. The whale (indeed the whole universe in his trilogy in four parts) is meaningless.
Does science deny teleology? More specifically, is modern science dysteleological? Is purpose only apparent (teleonomy)? I think there are 4 areas where the challenge lies.
1. Ontological dysteleology. There is something rather than nothing because there is something. The weak anthropic principle (we see things suited for life because we are alive) with some sort of multiverse idea means there is no need for a creator. Things exist because they do.
2. Anthropological or evolutionary dysteleology. Humans are not unique: there have been other hominids that could have become dominant (H. Neanderthalensis for one); intelligence is neither unique (cuttlefish, corvids like crows, cetaceans such as whales) nor special - it has arisen by chance as an adaptation; the unrepeatable nature of natural selection is such that humans need not have arisen, play the tape of life again (Gould) and we would not be here.
3. Theodicean dysteleology. Suffering is ubiquitous, horrendous and gratuitous. Evolution gives rise to it. Survival occurs via competition. Species develop and become extinct. People get cancer. Species parasitise other species. No good God created this as it is the result of blind chance.
4. Eschatological dysteleology. The destiny of the planet is to boil in an expanding solar envelope. The second law of thermodynamics ensures that the expanding universe (at an accelerating rate) ensures that complex life will one day disappear, that all information processing will come to an end in a void of simple particles as even protons eventually decay.
Pretty depressing huh? Is there a theological answer? Stay tuned.
However, reading part of The God Delusion we find Richard Dawkins putting Douglas Adams up as a poster boy for atheism motivated by science. Adams has his epiphany after reading The Selfish Gene and embracing a new enthusiasm for atheism and absurdity. The whale (indeed the whole universe in his trilogy in four parts) is meaningless.
Does science deny teleology? More specifically, is modern science dysteleological? Is purpose only apparent (teleonomy)? I think there are 4 areas where the challenge lies.
1. Ontological dysteleology. There is something rather than nothing because there is something. The weak anthropic principle (we see things suited for life because we are alive) with some sort of multiverse idea means there is no need for a creator. Things exist because they do.
2. Anthropological or evolutionary dysteleology. Humans are not unique: there have been other hominids that could have become dominant (H. Neanderthalensis for one); intelligence is neither unique (cuttlefish, corvids like crows, cetaceans such as whales) nor special - it has arisen by chance as an adaptation; the unrepeatable nature of natural selection is such that humans need not have arisen, play the tape of life again (Gould) and we would not be here.
3. Theodicean dysteleology. Suffering is ubiquitous, horrendous and gratuitous. Evolution gives rise to it. Survival occurs via competition. Species develop and become extinct. People get cancer. Species parasitise other species. No good God created this as it is the result of blind chance.
4. Eschatological dysteleology. The destiny of the planet is to boil in an expanding solar envelope. The second law of thermodynamics ensures that the expanding universe (at an accelerating rate) ensures that complex life will one day disappear, that all information processing will come to an end in a void of simple particles as even protons eventually decay.
Pretty depressing huh? Is there a theological answer? Stay tuned.
Labels:
dysteleology,
Orthodox theology,
science,
teleology
Monday, June 18, 2007
For what is Man in nature?
For what is Man in nature? A nothingness in respect to infinity, a whole in respect to nothingness, a median between nothingness and everything.
Blaise Pascal, Les Pensees
I have just started Our Cosmic Origins: From the Big Bang to the emergence of life and intelligence by Armand Delsemme. A fairly broad range of topics to address (and I expect in a typically reductionist manner). The above quote is interesting, and reminds me of Psalm 8
4What is man that You take thought of him,
And the son of man that You care for him?
5Yet You have made him a little lower than God,
And You crown him with glory and majesty! (NASB)
Human beings are more than nothing but less than everything, well duh! Isn't every being that ever was somewhere on that continuum? Where do we sit? Is it flat? Are we privileged somehow? If so, how? The Psalm puts our significane in our election by God to be something more than the other creatures
You make him to rule over the works of Your hands;
You have put all things under his feet,
7All sheep and oxen,
And also the beasts of the field,
8The birds of the heavens and the fish of the sea,
Whatever passes through the paths of the seas.
Does this promote arrogance? I'd think not when the Psalm finishes
9O LORD, our Lord,
How majestic is Your name in all the earth!
Of course one may counter that it promotes Divine arrogance, but if God is the creator, well then hubris seems less likely on his account.
One wonders too that while man (i.e. humanity) is more than nothing, given that we all move towards (and will, all other things being equal as a species) nothingness, where does meaning lay? For now, the last word to Job 19
26"Even after my skin is destroyed,
Yet from my flesh I shall see God" (NASB)
Blaise Pascal, Les Pensees
I have just started Our Cosmic Origins: From the Big Bang to the emergence of life and intelligence by Armand Delsemme. A fairly broad range of topics to address (and I expect in a typically reductionist manner). The above quote is interesting, and reminds me of Psalm 8
4What is man that You take thought of him,
And the son of man that You care for him?
5Yet You have made him a little lower than God,
And You crown him with glory and majesty! (NASB)
Human beings are more than nothing but less than everything, well duh! Isn't every being that ever was somewhere on that continuum? Where do we sit? Is it flat? Are we privileged somehow? If so, how? The Psalm puts our significane in our election by God to be something more than the other creatures
You make him to rule over the works of Your hands;
You have put all things under his feet,
7All sheep and oxen,
And also the beasts of the field,
8The birds of the heavens and the fish of the sea,
Whatever passes through the paths of the seas.
Does this promote arrogance? I'd think not when the Psalm finishes
9O LORD, our Lord,
How majestic is Your name in all the earth!
Of course one may counter that it promotes Divine arrogance, but if God is the creator, well then hubris seems less likely on his account.
One wonders too that while man (i.e. humanity) is more than nothing, given that we all move towards (and will, all other things being equal as a species) nothingness, where does meaning lay? For now, the last word to Job 19
26"Even after my skin is destroyed,
Yet from my flesh I shall see God" (NASB)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)